How to Choose an Accountant: A Guide for Australian Creatives

Author

Gracie Sinclair

Category

Date

20 November 2026
Accountant going through financial documents on a tablet with clients at a wooden table during a consultation
The information provided in this article is general in nature and does not constitute financial, tax, or legal advice. While we strive for accuracy, Australian tax laws change frequently. Always consult with a qualified professional before making decisions based on this content. Our team cannot be held liable for actions taken based on this information.
Need personalised financial guidance? Let's talk!

How to choose an accountant comes down to five checks. Confirm they are a registered tax agent. Test whether they understand how creative income works. See whether they explain things in plain English. Get the fee structure in writing before any work starts. Find out whether they talk to you during the year or only at tax time.

Credentials are the easy part, and most people stop there. The harder part is fit, and fit decides whether the relationship is useful or just one more bill. Think of it like auditioning a bass player. Everyone who turns up can play the notes. You want the one who locks in with the drummer, listens, and still turns up to rehearsal in March. This guide is for musicians, designers, photographers, writers, actors and the rest of the creative crowd, and it covers what to listen for at each stage.

Get the credentials sorted, then move on

Start with registration, because it isn't optional. Only registered tax agents can prepare and lodge tax returns for clients, and the Tax Practitioners Board keeps a public register you can search to check anyone's status. Membership of a professional body such as Chartered Accountants Australia and New Zealand, CPA Australia or the Institute of Public Accountants is another useful signal. Full members have completed their professional qualifications and have to keep up ongoing professional development to stay members. Advice about investing or retirement planning is a separate field again: it requires an Australian financial services (AFS) licence, which many accountants do not hold (Moneysmart, 2026).

That last point matters more than people expect. An accountant is not automatically a financial adviser. A good one will tell you plainly where their role ends.

Titles cause confusion too. A bookkeeper, a BAS agent and a tax agent are not interchangeable, and the register shows which registration a practitioner holds. If someone is vague about theirs, treat that as your answer.

Responsibility is the one people forget. Even when an accountant prepares your return, you remain legally responsible for what is lodged in your name, and a good accountant will explain this and make sure you understand what you are signing (Moneysmart, 2026). This is where credentials meet communication. An accountant who hands you a document and points at the signature line hasn't done the full job.

Industry understanding: does this accountant know how creatives earn?

Industry knowledge is the check with the biggest impact on how useful an accountant turns out to be. Creative income doesn't look like a salary, and an accountant who mostly works with salaried employees or a single type of business may not have the right picture of it.

The latest major study of Australian artists shows the shape of the problem. Most artists (78%) work on a self-employed or freelance basis in their creative work, and only 9% work full-time solely on their creative practice, with the other 91% also doing arts-related and non-arts work (Creative Australia, 2024). The juggling is getting more precarious. 59% of artists now work freelance or self-employed in arts-related work, up from 40%, and 56% do the same in non-arts work, up from 26% (Creative Australia, 2024).

In practice that means a year made up of gig fees, commissions, royalties, a grant, streaming payouts, some teaching, maybe a casual job and a sponsorship deal paid by an overseas platform. Add a gear upgrade, a home studio, travel to shoots or tours, and an ABN (Australian Business Number, the identifier you use when trading as a business). That is a lot of moving parts. How each one is treated for tax depends on your circumstances, and a registered tax agent is the right person to explain how the rules apply to you. The question when choosing an accountant is simpler: does this person recognise those moving parts without you having to explain each one?

A useful test in a first meeting is to describe your last year in a couple of sentences and see what comes back. An accountant who knows the sector will ask follow-up questions about things like royalty statements, grant conditions, platform payouts or how you separate business and personal spending. One who doesn't will ask you to send "everything" and sort it out later. It is also fair to ask whether they work with other people in your field, and what kind of issues tend to come up for them.

We started Amplify 11 on this idea. The firm is led by a Chartered Accountant who is also a working lead guitarist, so the gig economy isn't something we read about.

Test the communication instead of asking about it

Most guides tell you to ask about response times. Any firm will say it replies quickly. A first meeting tells you more than the answer to that question does, if you treat it as a trial run.

Pay attention to the language. Ask them to explain something basic, such as what a BAS is (a business activity statement, the form businesses use to report GST and some other tax amounts to the ATO), or what PAYG instalments are (regular prepayments towards your expected income tax). If the explanation is clear and short, you'll probably get that kind of clarity all year. If it comes buried in jargon, expect that too. Understanding your own numbers is part of running a creative business, and an accountant who explains things properly helps with that.

Then cover the practical side. Find out who will actually look after your work day to day, and whether that is the person in the room. Ask how documents are shared: through a portal, by email, or directly in your bookkeeping software. If your books are already in Xero, an accountant who works in Xero saves a lot of exporting and re-keying. Ask how concerns or complaints are handled. A clear answer here shows a practice that has thought about the relationship and isn't just processing work.

Location matters less than it used to. Neither of the major government guides on this topic says your accountant has to be local. Location is one priority to weigh alongside quality, reliability and price. For creatives, sector knowledge and a working style that suits you count for more than a short drive. A photographer in Hobart can work well with an accountant in Western Sydney if documents move easily and the calls actually happen.

Fixed pricing keeps the conversation going

How an accountant charges shapes how often you talk to them. It is reasonable to ask how fees are charged, whether you will be billed monthly or annually, and whether they bill for every phone call (Small Business Development Corporation).

That last question carries more weight than it seems. When every call or email starts a clock running, people stop calling. They sit on the question about whether to register for GST, or how to handle a grant, or what the PAYG instalment notice means. Then it turns up months later as a bigger, more expensive problem.

If every phone call costs money, people stop calling, and the accountant hears about the problem when it's already a tax bill.

Fixed-price packages take that hesitation away. You know the cost in advance, so picking up the phone doesn't feel like a decision. For people with lumpy income, a predictable fee also tends to be easier to budget for than an invoice that arrives after the work is done and depends on how many hours were logged.

A fixed price is only as good as its scope, though. The engagement letter (the written agreement setting out the work and the fee) should list what's included, such as the annual return, BAS lodgements, bookkeeping support or catch-up calls. It should also say what would trigger an extra charge. If an accountant can't put that in writing before starting, keep looking.

Year-round planning beats the June scramble

An accountant who only appears once a year is doing compliance: lodging what has already happened. That's necessary, but it is the minimum. The more valuable work happens before the end of the income year, while there is still time to make decisions.

A useful question is to ask for examples of how they have been proactive with other small business clients, such as helping prepare cash-flow forecasts. The moments that matter most include starting, buying or selling a business, expanding, running into credit or cash-flow problems, and taking on staff. Ideally you find an accountant before you start a business, not after (Small Business Development Corporation).

For creatives, those moments look like specific things. You get your first ABN. Your income starts to approach the point where GST becomes a question. A grant lands. You plan a big gear or software purchase. An overseas platform starts paying you regularly. You consider bringing on an assistant or changing your business structure as the work grows. Each of these is easier to talk through in advance. Regular check-ins during the year can mean fewer surprises at tax time and a clearer view of cash flow between gigs. They don't guarantee a smaller tax bill, and no honest accountant will promise one. What they can offer is time to plan.

It also helps to ask how they keep clients informed when the rules change, whether through newsletters, short updates or a call when something relevant happens. Registered tax practitioners have obligations to keep clients informed about certain matters, and it is reasonable to ask any accountant to explain what those are.

How to choose an accountant: a shortlist that actually works

Narrow the field to two or three practices and score each one against the same priorities. The table below turns the earlier sections into questions for a first meeting.

What you're testing Question to ask What a good answer sounds like
Registration "Are you a registered tax agent, and which professional body are you a member of?" A direct answer you can confirm on the public register
Industry understanding "What tends to come up for clients who earn the way I do?" Specific follow-up questions about your income streams, without you prompting
Communication "Who will I deal with, and how do we share documents?" A named contact and a clear process that fits the tools you already use
Pricing "How do you charge, and is a phone call billed?" A written scope and fee, with any extras spelled out
Planning "When would we talk during the year?" Set check-ins before key dates, not only a reminder in June
Boundaries "What can't you help me with?" A clear line on financial product and legal matters, with a referral path

Some warning signs are worth knowing before the first meeting:

  • Fees calculated as a percentage of your refund, which puts the accountant's interest ahead of accuracy
  • Reluctance to confirm registration, or a registration that doesn't match the work being offered
  • Confident talk about investment products or super decisions from someone without an AFS licence
  • No written engagement letter, or a scope that stays vague when you ask about it
  • Pressure to sign documents without being walked through them

To get the most out of a first meeting, bring a rough summary of last year's portfolio income streams, access to your existing bookkeeping software and your recent lodgement documents. That gives the accountant enough to ask useful questions straight away. If you already have an accountant who isn't the right fit, changing is usually simple. The new practice can explain how your records are handed over, so a poor fit shouldn't keep you where you are.

Contracts, partnership agreements and copyright questions come up in creative work all the time, and they belong with a lawyer or the Arts Law Centre of Australia, not your accountant. A good accountant will say so instead of guessing.

Keep interviewing until you find someone you're comfortable with. You'll be sharing your income, your spending and your plans with this person, and that only works if you trust them.

This article is general information only, reflects the rules at the time of writing, and does not take your personal circumstances into account.

Ready to crank your finances up to 11? Give the Amplify 11 team a ring on (02) 4715 1000 or email [email protected], and we'll help keep your numbers in tune while you get on with the music.

Can I switch accountants partway through the income year?

Yes. Changing accountants mid-year is common and generally straightforward. The new practice usually asks for your authority to be added as your tax agent and requests prior records, such as last year's return, working papers and bookkeeping files. Unpaid fees with the previous accountant can complicate the handover of some documents, so it helps to settle accounts. A registered tax agent can confirm what records they need from you.

Do I need an accountant if I only earn a little from my creative work?

There is no rule requiring one. Many people with simple affairs lodge their own returns. Creative income often mixes several sources, though, and even small amounts can raise questions about ABNs, record keeping and what counts as business income. Whether professional help is worth it depends on your circumstances, and a registered tax agent can explain how the rules apply to your situation before you decide.

What should I bring to a first meeting with a new accountant?

Useful items include your most recent notice of assessment, last year's tax return, a rough list of income sources for the current year, details of any ABN or GST registration, and access to your bookkeeping software if you use it. Bring any ATO letters you have received and a short list of questions. That lets the accountant see your situation quickly and gives you a fair test of how they respond.

Is it a problem if my accountant uses different software from me?

Not necessarily, but it can add friction. If your books are in one system and the accountant works in another, data may need exporting, reformatting or re-entering, which takes time and can introduce errors. Asking early which platforms a practice supports helps avoid this. Some people choose to move their bookkeeping into the accountant's preferred software, which is a decision best discussed during the first meeting.

How do I make a complaint about a tax agent?

Start by raising the issue directly with the practice, since many problems can be resolved through its own complaints process. If that does not work, concerns about a registered tax agent's conduct can be raised with the Tax Practitioners Board. Members of professional bodies such as CA ANZ or CPA Australia are also subject to those bodies' disciplinary processes. Fee disputes or contract issues may need advice from a lawyer.

Share on

TURN YOUR CREATIVE BUSINESS UP TO 11!

Sign up to receive relevant advice for your business.

Subscription Form
* The information provided on this website and blog is general in nature only and does not constitute financial, legal, or professional advice. While we strive to ensure accuracy and currency of information, no warranties or representations are made regarding its completeness or suitability for your circumstances, and you should always consult with an appropriate qualified professional advisor before acting on any information presented here. Under no circumstances shall Amplify 11 be liable for any loss or damage arising from reliance on information contained on this website.
chevron-down