Project Profitability for Creatives: Track It, Then Say No

Author

Gracie Sinclair

Date

16 November 2026
Hand holding a pen reviewing a project budget report with cost categories, bar chart and totals in warm light
The information provided in this article is general in nature and does not constitute financial, tax, or legal advice. While we strive for accuracy, Australian tax laws change frequently. Always consult with a qualified professional before making decisions based on this content. Our team cannot be held liable for actions taken based on this information.
Need personalised financial guidance? Let's talk!

Project profitability is the gap between what a job pays and what it actually costs to deliver. That cost includes your own hours at a realistic rate, materials, software and a fair slice of overheads. Getting paid is not the same as making money, and tracking time and costs per job is the only reliable way to see the difference.

That gap matters more for creatives than for almost anyone else. Most creative income arrives in pieces: a commission here, a gig there, some teaching, a royalty statement, a grant. Four in five Australian artists work freelance or self-employed, and only one in 10 works full time on their creative practice (Creative Australia, 2024). That research covers the 2021-22 financial year, so treat it as background rather than a snapshot of today, but the pattern is familiar to anyone juggling a portfolio career. When your hours are split across that many kinds of work, knowing which jobs actually pay is the whole game.

Most project profitability advice online is written for agency managers with timesheets and teams. This guide is for the sole trader or small creative business, where the person doing the work is also the person quoting, invoicing and chasing payment.

Why "I got paid" can still mean "I lost money"

A creative job has two layers of cost, and most people only count the first.

Direct costs belong to one job and disappear if the job does. Stock imagery and fonts for a design brief, hire gear for a shoot, strings and travel for a gig, printing for a zine. These are easy to remember because there is a receipt.

Indirect costs, or overheads, keep running whether you have work or not. Software subscriptions, insurance, your phone, a studio or rehearsal space, accounting fees, website hosting, gear that wears out over years rather than on one job. None of them appear on any single invoice, which is exactly why they get forgotten when quoting.

This is where gross and net margin come apart. Gross margin is what remains after direct costs, expressed as a share of the fee. Net margin is what remains after overheads too. A design job can show a gross margin that looks spectacular and still leave you underpaid once the hours and the overheads are counted honestly. The third cost, and the one creatives most often leave out entirely, is their own time.

Find your real hourly floor before you price anything

Every profitability test needs a benchmark: the minimum effective hourly rate a job has to clear for your business to work. Government pricing guidance says an hourly rate should spread all your business costs across your hours, including wages, super, leave entitlements and taxes (business.gov.au). How tax and super apply to a sole trader depends on individual circumstances, and a registered tax agent can explain how they apply to you.

The trap is the denominator. Business Queensland warns that sole traders tend to overestimate how many days, and how many hours a day, they can actually work, and that leave needs to be built in (Business Queensland). Holidays, sick days, quoting, invoicing, chasing late payers, bookkeeping, marketing and creative development all eat into the hours anyone can bill.

Here is a simplified illustration using round hypothetical numbers. Real outcomes depend entirely on individual circumstances.

A creative wants $80,000 a year from the business before tax, and expects $12,000 a year in overheads, so the business needs to bring in $92,000. If they divide that by a full-time year of 52 weeks at 38 hours (1,976 hours), they arrive at about $46.56 an hour. Now assume a more honest picture: 46 working weeks after holidays and sick days, and 25 billable hours in each of those weeks once admin is stripped out. That is 1,150 billable hours, and the floor becomes $80 an hour.

The naive rate is barely more than half the real one. Anyone quoting from the first number is underpricing every job before it starts, and no amount of hustle fixes a broken denominator.

Tracking time and costs per job without hating it

Tracking does not need to be elaborate. It needs to be consistent and attached to the job, not to the week. A basic setup records these items for every project:

  • Every hour spent, split into billable work and non-billable work such as revisions outside the brief, client calls, travel and admin.
  • The hours originally estimated in the quote, so actuals can be compared against them.
  • Every direct cost, tagged to the job in your bookkeeping (Xero can assign income and expenses to individual projects or tracking categories).
  • The date the invoice went out and the date the money landed.

The estimate-versus-actual comparison is the most valuable habit here. After a dozen jobs, patterns appear: logo projects that always run long, video edits that double at the feedback stage, a particular client type that needs twice the hand-holding. Those patterns become the raw material for better quotes. A simple timer app, a spreadsheet or the time-tracking inside your accounting software all work. The best tool is the one that actually gets used on a Tuesday afternoon when you are tired.

The other habit worth building is checking a job while it is still underway. A post-mortem tells you what went wrong. A mid-job check, at the halfway point or before a second round of revisions, tells you while there is still time to have a scope conversation with the client.

Measuring project profitability, job by job

The real test is simple: subtract direct costs from the fee, then divide by every hour the job took, billed or not. That gives the effective hourly rate, before overheads. Compare it with the floor.

Three hypothetical jobs, using the illustrative floor from the previous section. These are round numbers for illustration only.

Hypothetical job Fee Direct costs Total hours tracked Effective hourly rate Clears the floor?
Brand identity, flat fee $3,000 $200 40 $70 No
Event photography package $2,500 $150 22 about $106.82 Yes
Corporate function gig $600 $60 9 (incl. rehearsal and travel) $60 No

The brand identity job is the instructive one. On a gross margin basis it looks excellent, about 93% of the fee left after direct costs. It felt fine. Then the timesheet shows that 12 of those hours were unbilled revisions, 30% of the entire job. Against the floor, the designer worked the equivalent of $400 short, because 40 hours at the floor rate needed $3,200 and the job delivered $2,800 after costs.

Cap the revisions so the job lands at 28 hours and the same fee works out to $100 an hour. Nothing about the creative work changed. The only change is a sentence in the quote that defines what is included.

The gig is a different problem. The fee looks reasonable for a few hours on stage, but rehearsal, load-in, travel and pack-down are all part of the job. Musicians who price on stage time alone are pricing a fraction of the work.

Spotting the work that drains you

Draining jobs rarely announce themselves. They feel busy and slightly annoying, and then the numbers come back thin. The usual causes show up again and again.

Unlimited revision rounds sit at the top. A brief that says "until the client is happy" is an open-ended commitment of your time at a fixed price. Slow approvals come next: waiting on feedback stalls a project, pushes it into weeks you had planned for other work, and forces you to reload the whole job into your head every time it restarts. Scope creep is the quiet one, where an extra social tile, a second edit, or a quick extra track gets added without anyone mentioning the fee. Then there is the unbilled admin of endless emails, calls, file wrangling and chasing payment.

Pricing structure shapes which of these hurts. A fixed fee rewards efficiency but absorbs every overrun. Time-and-materials billing, where the client pays for hours and costs as they occur, protects you from overruns but caps upside and makes some clients nervous. For creative work, a fixed fee with a written scope, a set number of revision rounds and an hourly rate for anything beyond them tends to balance both.

Time tracking is a diagnostic tool, not a pricing philosophy. Government guidance describes value pricing as charging for the value a customer receives rather than only your costs, so work that saves a client time or offers something unique may support a higher price, and it recommends reviewing prices at least once a year or whenever costs or the market change (business.gov.au). A track that becomes a brand's signature sound, or a photo that sells a property, is worth more than the hours behind it. Tracking tells you the floor; value tells you how far above it a job can sit.

Deciding when to say no

Saying no is a business decision, and it is easier to make with numbers in front of you than with a knot in your stomach.

The creative sector already runs on underpriced labour. Professor David Throsby, lead researcher on the Artists as Workers study, described it as "a form of subsidy", with artists "prepared to work for much lower rates of return" to support the country's cultural output (ABC News, 2024). The same research found just 21% of artists meet their minimum income needs from creative work alone (Creative Australia, 2024). Every job priced below the floor adds to that subsidy, and it comes out of your rent, your gear budget and your time for your own work.

A job that pays below your floor is not a job. It is a donation with deadlines.

That does not mean every low-paying job is a mistake. Some are deliberate: a portfolio piece, a cause you care about, a door into a new client. The difference is choosing the discount knowingly rather than discovering it in the timesheet. A simple framework for weighing a job looks like this:

  1. Does the quoted fee, divided by realistically estimated hours (including revisions and admin), clear the floor?
  2. If not, is there a specific, nameable reason to accept it, such as a portfolio gap or a strategic relationship, and a limit on how often that reason gets used?
  3. Has this client or job type run over before, according to your own tracking?
  4. Is the scope written down, with revision rounds capped and extra work priced?
  5. What other work would this job displace, including your own creative practice?

When the answers keep pointing the wrong way, the options are to reprice, rescope or decline. Repricing an existing client is uncomfortable, and Business Queensland makes the point that it is much easier to lower prices than to raise them, adding that a price far below competitors can signal low quality to customers (Business Queensland). That cuts both ways. Starting high leaves room to negotiate, while starting low locks in a rate that is painful to climb out of. Pricing also has legal edges, such as agreements with competitors over prices or misleading price claims, so anything in that territory is a question for a lawyer or the Arts Law Centre of Australia.

Dropping a client who consistently lands under the floor can feel like losing income. In many cases it frees hours for better-paid work or for the creative practice that got you into this in the first place, though the effect depends on what fills the space. Tracking makes that call visible rather than emotional, and a regular review of which clients and job types clear the floor can turn a vague sense of being overworked into a clear list of what to change.

This article is general information only, reflects the rules at the time of writing, and does not take your personal circumstances into account. If your jobs feel busy but your bank balance sounds out of tune, the Amplify 11 team would love to help you find the setlist that actually pays. Give us a ring on (02) 4715 1000 or drop a line to [email protected], and let's crank your numbers up to 11.

How do I track profitability if I get paid in royalties or streaming income months after the work?

Delayed income can be logged against the original project as it arrives, so the job's effective hourly rate keeps updating over time. Some creatives keep a running record for each release or licensed work, adding every statement as it lands. This shows which projects keep earning long after the hours were spent, which is useful when weighing up similar work later.

Should grant-funded projects be included in project profitability tracking?

Grant-funded work can be tracked the same way as any other job, with hours, direct costs and the grant amount recorded against the project. Grants often come with acquittal and reporting obligations, so that admin time belongs in the hours total. How grant income is treated for tax depends on the grant and your circumstances, and a registered tax agent can explain how it applies to you.

What if a client refuses to agree to a revision limit in the quote?

A client unwilling to accept any scope limit is giving useful information about how the job is likely to run. Some creatives respond by quoting a higher fixed fee that allows for extra rounds, or by switching that client to hourly billing. Contract wording itself is a legal matter, so a lawyer or the Arts Law Centre of Australia can help with terms.

How many jobs do I need to track before the data is useful?

Patterns usually start to show after a handful of similar jobs, and become clearer after ten or more. The aim is to see whether particular job types, clients or stages consistently run over the estimate. Even a short history tends to be more reliable than memory, which usually forgets the unbilled emails, calls and revisions that make a job feel busier than expected.

Share on

TURN YOUR CREATIVE BUSINESS UP TO 11!

Sign up to receive relevant advice for your business.

Subscription Form
* The information provided on this website and blog is general in nature only and does not constitute financial, legal, or professional advice. While we strive to ensure accuracy and currency of information, no warranties or representations are made regarding its completeness or suitability for your circumstances, and you should always consult with an appropriate qualified professional advisor before acting on any information presented here. Under no circumstances shall Amplify 11 be liable for any loss or damage arising from reliance on information contained on this website.
chevron-down